Checkpoints and Lives: How to Make a Hard Level Feel Fair
By the devbox.studio team at Forging Destiny Studios, LLC
Quick answer
A hard level feels fair when players lose little progress for each mistake. Put a checkpoint right after each tough section, give 3 to 5 lives for most games, and make sure every hazard is visible before it matters. In devbox.studio, spikes and enemies cost a life with a short moment of safety afterward, while lava and falling are instant.
Players do not mind dying. They mind dying and having to repeat the boring part again. Checkpoints and lives are how you control that.
How it works in devbox.studio
- Lives: set in the Controls tab, from 1 to 9. The default is 3.
- Checkpoints: paint a checkpoint tile. When the player touches it, it lights up and plays a sound, and after losing a life the player comes back there instead of at the start.
- Hazards: touching spikes or an enemy from the side costs a life, then the hero blinks for a moment and cannot be hurt again right away. Lava and falling off the bottom of the level cost a life instantly.
Where to put checkpoints
- Right after a hard section, not right before it. The player has earned it.
- Before a new idea, so experimenting with it is cheap.
- Every 40 to 60 tiles in a long level, as a rough guide.
- On safe, flat ground, so players do not come back into danger.
How many lives?
- 1 life: for short, intense challenge levels. Make them very short.
- 3 lives: the classic. Works for most levels with checkpoints.
- 5 or more: for younger players, long levels, or levels with lots of new ideas.
If players keep running out of lives, more lives is a band-aid. A better fix is usually a checkpoint or making the hard part clearer.
Make danger readable
The Lava Castle template is hard, but every lava pit is in plain sight. Hard is fine. Hidden is not. Before you add a checkpoint, ask whether the player could have avoided the mistake if they had been paying attention. If not, fix the level instead.
The difficulty checklist
- Can the player see every hazard before it hurts them?
- Is there a checkpoint after each section that took you more than two tries?
- Is the walk back from the checkpoint to the hard part short?
- Does losing a life feel like "my fault" rather than "the game's fault"?
For pacing difficulty across a whole level, read our level design tips.
Frequently asked questions
Where should checkpoints go in a platformer?
Right after difficult sections and before new ideas, on safe flat ground, roughly every 40 to 60 tiles in a long level.
How many lives should a platformer give?
Three is a good default when the level has checkpoints. Give more for younger players or long levels, and one for short challenge levels.